Community
Featured tasting notes and public reviews from fellow collectors.
Elijah Craig
Barrel Proof B521
Cask-strength Kentucky bourbon — deep oak, dark fruit, and warm baking spice.
nose: Vanilla, oak, dark cherry
palate: Rich caramel, baking spice, brown sugar
finish: Long, warm, oaky
complexity: High
value: Excellent
Featured Tastings
Cellar & Humidor EditorialBand Book Highlights
Browse all
From the Community
Member activityAlec Bradley
Alec Bradley Tempus Nemesis
Cigar
Bold and flavorful
A full-bodied smoke with great complexity. The Honduran wrapper adds a unique character. Not for beginners.
flavor: Cedar, spice, earth, leather
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
Hoyo de Monterrey
Hoyo de Monterrey Epicure No. 2
Cigar
Smooth Cuban
A great medium-bodied Cuban. Creamy and smooth with cedar notes. Perfect for when you don't want something too strong.
flavor: Cedar, cream, nuts, honey
burn: Even
strength: Medium
Buy again: Yes
Macanudo
Macanudo Inspirado Robusto
Cigar
Smooth and mild
A step up from the classic Macanudo. Still mild and smooth but with more flavor. Good for beginners.
flavor: Cedar, cream, nuts, vanilla
burn: Even
strength: Medium
Buy again: Maybe
Oliva
Oliva Serie G Maduro Robusto
Cigar
Great value maduro
Rich and sweet with a nice maduro wrapper. Good construction and consistent flavor. Excellent everyday smoke.
flavor: Cocoa, cedar, coffee, cream
burn: Even
strength: Medium-Full
Buy again: Yes
La Flor Dominicana
La Flor Dominicana Andalusian Bull
Cigar
Unique and bold
The bull shape is unique and the flavor is bold and complex. Full-bodied with great construction. A standout cigar.
flavor: Cedar, spice, leather, earth
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
Arturo Fuente
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Between the Lines
Cigar
Classic Dominican
A perfectly constructed perfecto. The Cameroon wrapper adds a beautiful sweetness. Medium-full with great complexity.
flavor: Cedar, nuts, spice, cream
burn: Even
strength: Medium-Full
Buy again: Yes
Cohiba
Cohiba Behike BHK 52
Cigar
The holy grail of cigars
If you can find one, it's extraordinary. The flavor is rich and complex from start to finish. Worth the exorbitant price for a once-in-a-lifetime smoke.
flavor: Cedar, coffee, earth, pepper
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
Camacho
Camacho Corojo Robusto
Cigar
Authentic Corojo
Bold and spicy. The Corojo wrapper is distinctive. A bit one-dimensional but enjoyable if you like full-bodied cigars.
flavor: Spice, earth, cedar, pepper
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Maybe
Romeo y Julieta
Romeo y Julieta 1875 Bully
Cigar
Decent everyday smoke
A solid medium-bodied cigar. Nothing spectacular but consistently good and affordable. Good for a quick smoke.
flavor: Cedar, nuts, cream, mild spice
burn: Even
strength: Medium
Buy again: Maybe
Perdomo
Perdomo 10 Year Anniversary Robusto
Cigar
Great value
Well-constructed and flavorful. The 10-year aging adds smoothness. Good medium-full body with nice spice.
flavor: Cedar, spice, cream, nuts
burn: Even
strength: Medium-Full
Buy again: Yes
Joya de Nicaragua
Joya de Nicaragua Antano 1970
Cigar
Nicaraguan powerhouse
One of the strongest cigars I've smoked. Full-bodied and intense. Not for the faint of heart but incredible if you like bold cigars.
flavor: Earth, pepper, cedar, leather
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
Padron
Padron 1964 Anniversary Imperial
Cigar
A benchmark cigar
Everything you want in a cigar. Perfect construction, rich flavor, and incredible consistency. The 4-year aging shows. Cocoa and pepper throughout.
flavor: Cocoa, coffee, cedar, pepper
burn: Even
strength: Medium-Full
Buy again: Yes
Partagas
Partagas Serie D No. 4
Cigar
The best Cuban
A quintessential Cuban cigar. Rich, full-bodied, and complex. The construction is perfect and the flavor development is remarkable.
flavor: Earth, cedar, coffee, pepper
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
Nub
Nub Habano 460
Cigar
Short and intense
The concept works. A short, fat cigar that hits its sweet spot immediately. Full-flavored from the first puff.
flavor: Spice, cedar, earth, coffee
burn: Even
strength: Medium-Full
Buy again: Yes
Monkey Shoulder
Monkey Shoulder
Spirits
Great mixing scotch
Designed for cocktails but surprisingly good neat. Smooth, sweet, and approachable. Perfect for an old fashioned.
nose: Vanilla, honey, orange
finish: Medium, sweet, smooth
palate: Malt, spice, oak
Buy again: Yes
Wild Turkey
Wild Turkey 101
Spirits
Bold and spicy
A punchy bourbon at 101 proof. Great value and full of flavor. The heat might be too much for some but I love it.
nose: Caramel, vanilla, pepper
finish: Long, warm, spicy
palate: Oak, honey, spice
Buy again: Yes
Johnnie Walker
Johnnie Walker Black Label
Spirits
Reliable blended scotch
A decent everyday blend. The smoke is there but not overpowering. Good value but lacks the complexity of single malts.
nose: Smoke, raisins, vanilla
finish: Medium, smoky
palate: Spice, oak, malt
Buy again: Maybe
Clase Azul
Clase Azul Reposado
Spirits
Beautiful bottle, good tequila
The bottle is stunning and the tequila is smooth and sweet. Overpriced for the liquid but a great gift.
nose: Vanilla, caramel, agave
finish: Smooth, sweet, warm
palate: Oak, cinnamon, citrus
Buy again: Maybe
Macallan
Macallan 18 Sherry Oak
Spirits
Worth every penny
Incredible depth and complexity. The sherry cask influence is perfect. Dried fruits, ginger, and oak in harmony. A special occasion dram.
nose: Dried fruits, sherry, oak
finish: Very long, complex
palate: Ginger, vanilla, spice
Buy again: Yes
Laphroaig
Laphroaig 10 Year
Spirits
Love it or hate it
The medicinal peat is intense. I love it but I understand why some don't. The iodine and seaweed notes are unique. A quintessential Islay.
nose: Peat, iodine, seaweed
finish: Long, smoky, medicinal
palate: Smoke, vanilla, oak
Buy again: Yes
Glenlivet
Glenlivet 12 Year
Spirits
Reliable and smooth
You can always count on Glenlivet 12. It's not the most complex scotch but it's consistently good and great value.
nose: Honey, pineapple, floral
finish: Medium, smooth
palate: Vanilla, oak, fruit
Buy again: Yes
Fortaleza
Fortaleza Blanco
Spirits
The best blanco tequila
Pure agave perfection. No additives, just traditional tequila-making. The citrus and pepper notes are vibrant. Worth every penny.
nose: Agave, citrus, earth
finish: Clean, crisp, vibrant
palate: Pepper, vanilla, mineral
Buy again: Yes
Aberlour
Aberlour 12 Double Cask
Spirits
Rich and sherried
Great value for a sherried scotch. Chocolate and raisins throughout. Smooth and warming.
nose: Sherry, raisins, chocolate
finish: Medium, warm, sweet
palate: Oak, spice, dried fruit
Buy again: Yes
Tanqueray
Tanqueray No. Ten
Spirits
The best gin for martinis
Fresh, citrusy, and clean. The chamomile adds a unique touch. Perfect for a dry martini.
nose: Juniper, citrus, chamomile
finish: Clean, crisp, citrus
palate: Coriander, floral, juniper
Buy again: Yes
Glenfiddich
Glenfiddich 12 Year
Spirits
Classic Speyside
A great entry into single malts. Smooth, approachable, and widely available. The pear and vanilla notes are pleasant.
nose: Pear, oak, vanilla
finish: Medium, clean, sweet
palate: Malt, citrus, honey
Buy again: Yes
Talisker
Talisker 10 Year
Spirits
Coastal perfection
The maritime character is unique. Peppery and smoky with a beautiful saltiness. Perfect for a cold evening.
nose: Pepper, smoke, salt
finish: Long, peppery, warm
palate: Citrus, oak, brine
Buy again: Yes
Appleton Estate
Appleton Estate 12 Year
Spirits
Classic Jamaican rum
Rich and complex with great oak influence. The orange and almond notes are distinctive. Great neat or in a cocktail.
nose: Orange, oak, vanilla
finish: Medium, warm, sweet
palate: Almond, molasses, oak
Buy again: Yes
Nikka
Nikka From the Barrel
Spirits
Bold and unique
At 51.4% it's bold but incredibly well-balanced. Rich and full-bodied. A fantastic Japanese whisky.
nose: Vanilla, fruit, malt
finish: Long, warm, rich
palate: Oak, spice, caramel
Buy again: Yes
Remy Martin
Remy Martin XO
Spirits
Luxurious cognac
Rich, smooth, and complex. Dried fruits and cinnamon throughout. A fantastic after-dinner sipper.
nose: Dried fruit, cinnamon, oak
finish: Long, warm, complex
palate: Honey, spice, oak
Buy again: Yes
Macallan
Macallan 12 Double Cask
Spirits
Sherry lovers delight
The double cask gives it a beautiful balance of European and American oak. Dried fruits and ginger throughout.
nose: Dried fruits, oak, ginger
finish: Long, warm, spicy
palate: Sherry, vanilla, citrus
Buy again: Yes
Casamigos
Casamigos Reposado
Spirits
Celebrity tequila
Smooth and easy drinking but lacks complexity. Good for shots and cocktails. You're paying for the Clooney name.
nose: Vanilla, cocoa, agave
finish: Short, smooth, sweet
palate: Caramel, oak, citrus
Buy again: Maybe
Highland Park
Highland Park 12 Year
Spirits
Balanced and approachable
A great introduction to peated scotch. The heather honey sweetness balances the smoke perfectly. Not too aggressive.
nose: Heather honey, citrus
finish: Medium, sweet, smoky
palate: Smoke, malt, oak
Buy again: Yes
Four Roses
Four Roses Single Barrel
Spirits
Consistently excellent
Each barrel is unique but always good. Fruity and spicy with great depth. One of the best values in bourbon.
nose: Caramel, fruit, oak
finish: Long, warm, complex
palate: Spice, vanilla, oak
Buy again: Yes
Elijah Craig
Elijah Craig Small Batch
Spirits
Aged to perfection
12 years old and it shows. The baking spice and smoke notes are unique. Great value for an age-stated bourbon.
nose: Caramel, vanilla, oak
finish: Long, warm, spicy
palate: Baking spice, smoke, honey
Buy again: Yes
Ardbeg
Ardbeg 10 Year
Spirits
Peat monster
Even more intense than Laphroaig. The lemon and vanilla balance the peat surprisingly well. A fantastic Islay experience.
nose: Peat, lemon, vanilla
finish: Long, smoky, peppery
palate: Tar, black pepper, smoke
Buy again: Yes
Balvenie
Balvenie 12 DoubleWood
Spirits
Two casks, one great whisky
The combination of bourbon and sherry casks creates a beautiful balance. Honey and cinnamon throughout. Very drinkable.
nose: Honey, vanilla, oak
finish: Medium, warm, sweet
palate: Cinnamon, sherry, malt
Buy again: Yes
Johnnie Walker
Johnnie Walker Blue Label
Spirits
Smooth but overpriced
Incredibly smooth and drinkable but at this price I'd rather have a good single malt. Still, a well-crafted blend.
nose: Honey, smoke, dried fruit
finish: Long, smooth, warm
palate: Oak, vanilla, spice
Buy again: Maybe
Belvedere
Belvedere Vodka
Spirits
Smooth and clean
A premium vodka that's actually worth the price. Smooth neat and great in cocktails. The rye character comes through.
nose: Vanilla, rye, cream
finish: Clean, smooth, subtle
palate: White pepper, citrus, wheat
Buy again: Yes
Glenmorangie
Glenmorangie Original 10 Year
Spirits
Delicate and fruity
Very approachable. The vanilla and fruit notes from the ex-bourbon casks are lovely. A great everyday dram.
nose: Vanilla, orange, peach
finish: Medium, clean, sweet
palate: Geranium, oak, citrus
Buy again: Yes
AVO
AVO Heritage Toro
Cigar
Smooth and creamy
A great medium-bodied smoke. Creamy and smooth with cedar and nut notes. Perfect for a morning or afternoon when you don't want something too strong.
flavor: Cedar, cream, nuts, vanilla
burn: Even
strength: Medium
Buy again: Yes
Angel's Envy
Angel's Envy Cask Strength
Spirits
The port finish is magic
The port barrel finish transforms this bourbon. Dark cherry, chocolate, and baking spice. At cask strength it's intense but add a drop of water and it opens up beautifully.
nose: Port wine, cherry, vanilla
finish: Long, sweet, warm
palate: Dark chocolate, cherry, spice
Buy again: Yes
La Aroma de Cuba
La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor Robusto
Cigar
Solid and consistent
Good medium-full body with nice spice. Consistent construction. A great everyday smoke that won't break the bank.
flavor: Cedar, spice, earth
burn: Even
strength: Medium-Full
Buy again: Yes
AVO
AVO Heritage Toro
Cigar
Good but mild for me
Well-made and smooth but I prefer more punch. Great for beginners or a mild morning smoke. Construction is excellent.
flavor: Cedar, cream, toast
burn: Even
strength: Medium
Buy again: Maybe
Eagle Rare
Eagle Rare 10 Year
Spirits
Reliable and good
A solid everyday pour. Not as complex as Blanton's but consistently good and great value. Always have a bottle on my shelf.
Buy again: Yes
Rocky Patel
Rocky Patel Decade Toro
Cigar
Great smoke for the price
Well-constructed and flavorful. Not quite at the level of Padron or Liga Privada but at a fraction of the cost. Excellent everyday premium.
flavor: Chocolate, espresso, earth
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
Plantation
Plantation XO 20th Anniversary
Spirits
Very smooth
I don't drink much rum but this is genuinely excellent. Sweet and complex. Maybe a touch too sweet for me but I can see why people love it.
Buy again: Maybe
Patron
Patron Gran Platinum
Spirits
Smooth and clean
Very smooth for a blanco. The agave and citrus notes are fresh and bright. Great in a margarita or sipped neat.
nose: Agave, citrus, herbs
finish: Clean, crisp, short
palate: Pepper, vanilla, mineral
Buy again: Yes
Davidoff
Davidoff Royal Series
Cigar
Flawless construction
Davidoff never disappoints. The burn is perfect, the draw is ideal, and the flavors are sophisticated. Expensive but you get what you pay for.
flavor: Cedar, cream, nuts
burn: Even
strength: Medium-Full
Buy again: Yes
Ashton
Ashton VSG Wizard
Cigar
Great but strong
Very flavorful and well-constructed but definitely a full-bodied smoke. Not for the faint of heart. I enjoy it but can't smoke it every day.
flavor: Cedar, spice, earth
strength: Full
Buy again: Maybe
Montecristo
Montecristo White Toro
Cigar
A modern classic
Creamier and smoother than the original Montecristo. Great for when you want a milder smoke. The construction is excellent and the burn is even.
flavor: Cream, cedar, nuts, toast
burn: Even
strength: Medium
Buy again: Yes
Lagavulin
Lagavulin 16 Year
Spirits
The king of Islay
If you love peat, this is the benchmark. Medicinal smoke, brine, and a surprising sweetness underneath. Not for beginners but unforgettable once you acquire the taste.
nose: Peat smoke, seaweed, brine
finish: Long, smoky, salty
palate: Smoked meat, vanilla, oak
Buy again: Yes
Hennessy
Hennessy XO
Spirits
Worth every penny
You can taste the age and craftsmanship. Every sip reveals something new. Perfect for a cold evening by the fire.
Buy again: Yes
Davidoff
Davidoff Royal Series
Cigar
The definition of luxury
Impeccable construction and a refined, elegant flavor profile. This is what a premium cigar should be. Worth the premium price for special occasions.
flavor: Cedar, cream, nuts, spice, leather
burn: Even
strength: Medium-Full
Buy again: Yes
Padron
Padron Serie 1926 No. 9
Cigar
Even better than the 1964
Bolder and more intense than the 1964. The 5-year aging gives it incredible depth. Cocoa, coffee, and pepper in perfect balance. A true masterpiece.
flavor: Cocoa, coffee, cedar, pepper
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
Suntory
Hibiki Harmony
Spirits
Delicate and beautiful
Japanese whisky at its finest. Not peaty like Islay, not sweet like bourbon. Just perfectly balanced and elegant. The rose and honey notes are unique.
nose: Honey, rose, citrus
finish: Clean, medium, subtle
palate: Vanilla, oak, white pepper
Buy again: Yes
My Father
My Father Le Bijou 1922
Cigar
Incredibly well-made
Construction is perfect. The flavor profile is rich and layered. Full-bodied but never harsh. A must-try for any serious cigar smoker.
flavor: Cocoa, leather, cedar, pepper
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
Rocky Patel
Rocky Patel Decade Toro
Cigar
Incredible value
A 95-rated cigar at this price is remarkable. Rich, full-bodied, and complex. The 10-year aging shows. Dark chocolate and espresso throughout.
flavor: Dark chocolate, espresso, cedar, pepper
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
Suntory
Hibiki Harmony
Spirits
Refined but subtle
Very smooth and drinkable but maybe too delicate for my taste. I prefer more punch. Still, objectively excellent and well-crafted.
Buy again: Maybe
Eagle Rare
Eagle Rare 10 Year
Spirits
Incredible value for a 10-year
At this price point, nothing beats it. Rich, complex, and smooth. The toasted nut and honey notes make it special.
nose: Honey, caramel, nuts
finish: Long, warm, sweet
palate: Toasted almonds, oak, orange
Buy again: Yes
Plantation
Plantation XO 20th Anniversary
Spirits
Better than many whiskies
This rum rivals premium scotch for complexity and smoothness. Coconut, toffee, and dark chocolate. Incredible neat. A gateway rum for whiskey lovers.
nose: Coconut, vanilla, toffee
finish: Velvety, sweet, long
palate: Dark chocolate, banana, oak
Buy again: Yes
Drew Estate
Liga Privada No. 9
Cigar
Worth the hype
Rich, dark, and complex. The espresso and dark chocolate notes are incredible. Burns slow and cool. One of the best cigars I've ever smoked.
flavor: Chocolate, espresso, pepper, leather
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
Padron
Padron Serie 1926 No. 9
Cigar
Powerful and refined
Full-bodied but never harsh. The flavor development through the thirds is remarkable. Worth every penny.
flavor: Cocoa, coffee, pepper, earth
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
Lagavulin
Lagavulin 16 Year
Spirits
Too smoky for me
I can appreciate the craftsmanship but the peat is just too much for my palate. I prefer bourbon. Respect to the Islay fans though.
Buy again: No
Don Julio
Don Julio 1942
Spirits
Great but pricey for what it is
Very smooth and enjoyable but at this price I'd rather have a good scotch. Still, a fantastic sipping tequila for special occasions.
Buy again: Maybe
Glenfiddich
Glenfiddich 21 Year Gran Reserva
Spirits
The rum finish is delightful
The Caribbean rum cask finish adds a wonderful sweetness and depth. Toffee, fig, and a hint of lime. A unique and luxurious dram.
nose: Toffee, fig, banana
finish: Sweet, spicy, long
palate: Dark fruit, ginger, oak
Buy again: Yes
Blanton's
Blanton's Single Barrel Bourbon
Spirits
Excellent but overhyped
A genuinely great bourbon but the secondary market prices are insane. At retail it's a 5-star pour. At $200+ it's a 3-star value.
nose: Sweet corn, vanilla, caramel
finish: Warm, medium length
palate: Honey, citrus, oak
Buy again: Maybe
Don Julio
Don Julio 1942
Spirits
The tequila that changed my mind
I was a tequila skeptic until I tried this neat. Smooth, sweet, and complex. No burn at all. The vanilla and caramel notes are gorgeous.
nose: Vanilla, cooked agave, citrus
finish: Smooth, sweet, warm
palate: Caramel, cinnamon, oak
Buy again: Yes
Angel's Envy
Angel's Envy Cask Strength
Spirits
Unique but hot
The port finish is interesting and adds great flavor but at 127 proof it's a bit hot even with water. I prefer the standard Angel's Envy for everyday.
Buy again: Maybe
Drew Estate
Liga Privada No. 9
Cigar
Outstanding but hard to find
When you can get them, they're incredible. Full-bodied without being harsh. The construction is flawless. Worth the hunt.
flavor: Dark chocolate, earth, pepper
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
Ashton
Ashton VSG Wizard
Cigar
Classic and refined
A benchmark Dominican cigar. The VSG wrapper adds a beautiful spiciness. Cream and cedar throughout with a perfect burn. A classic for a reason.
flavor: Cedar, spice, leather, espresso
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
La Aroma de Cuba
La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor Robusto
Cigar
Love at first smoke
The name says it all. Rich, spicy, and incredibly well-balanced. The construction is flawless and the flavor profile is complex without being overwhelming.
flavor: Cedar, spice, dark chocolate, leather
burn: Even
strength: Medium-Full
Buy again: Yes
San Cristobal
San Cristobal Elegancia Toro
Cigar
Elegant and refined
True to its name. The Elegancia is smooth, balanced, and aromatic. The golden wrapper is beautiful. Cedar and cream notes throughout with a perfect burn.
flavor: Cedar, cream, nuts, honey
burn: Even
strength: Medium
Buy again: Yes
Blanton's
Blanton's Single Barrel Bourbon
Spirits
Lives up to the hype
Smooth, rich, and complex. The single barrel character really shines. Worth the hunt to find a bottle at retail.
nose: Caramel, vanilla, citrus
finish: Medium, warm, sweet
palate: Honey, oak, baking spice
Buy again: Yes
Hennessy
Hennessy XO
Spirits
The definition of elegance
Sophisticated, layered, and incredibly smooth. Dried fruit, oak, and spice in perfect balance. A true after-dinner classic.
nose: Dried fruit, oak, vanilla
finish: Long, warm, complex
palate: Chocolate, spice, leather
Buy again: Yes
Glenfiddich
Glenfiddich 21 Year Gran Reserva
Spirits
Elegant and sweet
Very enjoyable. The rum finish is subtle but adds nice complexity. Maybe a touch too sweet for daily drinking but perfect as a dessert dram.
Buy again: Maybe
San Cristobal
San Cristobal Elegancia Toro
Cigar
Great morning smoke
Smooth and mellow with nice complexity. Perfect with coffee. Not too strong but not boring either. Good construction and even burn.
flavor: Cedar, cream, toast, honey
burn: Even
strength: Medium
Buy again: Yes
Lagavulin
Lagavulin 16 Year
Spirits
Acquired taste worth acquiring
Brutal on the first sip but once you tune in, the complexity is staggering. The smoke never overwhelms the underlying sweetness.
nose: Heavy peat, iodine, citrus
finish: Very long, smoky
palate: Smoke, honey, salt
Buy again: Yes
My Father
My Father Le Bijou 1922
Cigar
A masterpiece
96 rating well deserved. The Habana Oscuro wrapper is gorgeous and the flavor is rich and complex from start to finish. Cocoa and pepper throughout.
flavor: Cocoa, coffee, cedar, black pepper
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
Montecristo
Montecristo White Toro
Cigar
Good but not memorable
A perfectly fine smoke but nothing stands out. Good for a mild, easygoing session. I'd reach for something with more character.
flavor: Cream, cedar, nuts
burn: Even
strength: Medium
Buy again: Maybe
Patron
Patron Gran Platinum
Spirits
Good but overpriced
It's smooth but at this price there are better tequilas. You're paying for the brand. Not bad, just not great value.
Buy again: Maybe
Oliva
Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro
Nicaragua
Arturo Fuente
Opus X Reserva d'Chateau
Dominican Republic
Cohiba
Cohiba Robusto
Cuba
Padron
Padron 1964 Anniversary Maduro
Nicaragua
Romeo y Julieta
Romeo y Julieta 1875 Churchill
Dominican Republic
Romeo y Julieta
Romeo y Julieta 1875 Churchill
Cigar
A reliable classic
Nothing wrong with it but nothing that blows me away either. Good everyday cigar with pleasant cedar and cream notes. Great value.
flavor: Cedar, cream, toast, nuts
burn: Slightly Uneven
strength: Medium
Buy again: Yes
Oliva
Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro
Cigar
Incredible value for a 94-rated cigar
Dark chocolate, espresso, and just enough pepper. The maduro wrapper is gorgeous and the construction is excellent. Hard to beat at this price.
flavor: Dark chocolate, espresso, cedar, leather
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
Macallan
Macallan 18 Year Sherry Oak
Spirits
A masterpiece in a glass
The sherry influence is incredible. Dried fruits, spice, and oak on the nose, with a finish that goes on forever. This is what scotch is all about.
nose: Dried fruits, ginger, oak sherry
finish: Long, warming, oak spice
palate: Rich sherry, cinnamon, dried figs
Buy again: Yes
Buffalo Trace
Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon
Spirits
Best value in bourbon, period
I keep coming back to this. Smooth, sweet, and approachable. At this price you can't go wrong. Works neat, on rocks, or in an Old Fashioned.
nose: Vanilla, caramel, corn
finish: Medium, sweet
palate: Brown sugar, oak, light spice
Buy again: Yes
Hendrick's
Hendrick's Gin
Spirits
Perfect for a summer G&T
The cucumber and rose make this unique. Not for everyone but fantastic in a gin and tonic with a cucumber garnish. Refreshing.
nose: Juniper, rose, cucumber
finish: Clean, crisp, cucumber
palate: Floral, citrus, juniper
Buy again: Yes
Woodford Reserve
Woodford Reserve Double Oaked
Spirits
Nice step up from standard
Enjoyable and rich. The extra oak is noticeable without being overpowering. Good value for a premium bourbon.
Buy again: Yes
Padron
Padron 1964 Anniversary Maduro
Cigar
The gold standard
Perfect construction, perfect burn, perfect flavor. Cocoa, coffee, and pepper throughout. This is what every cigar should aspire to be.
flavor: Cocoa, coffee, cedar, pepper
burn: Even
strength: Medium-Full
Buy again: Yes
Arturo Fuente
Arturo Fuente Opus X Reserva d'Chateau
Cigar
A religious experience
Full-bodied, complex, and powerful. The Dominican wrapper is unique and gives it a character unlike anything else. Worth every penny.
flavor: Cedar, leather, pepper, dark fruit
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
Diplomatico
Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva
Spirits
Sipping rum at its finest
If you think rum is just for mixing, try this. Toffee, chocolate, and dried fruit. Smooth as silk neat. One of the best values in spirits.
nose: Vanilla, toffee, dried fruit
finish: Sweet, long, velvety
palate: Chocolate, caramel, oak
Buy again: Yes
Diplomatico
Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva
Spirits
Surprised me
I'm a bourbon guy but this rum is excellent. Sweet and complex. Great after dinner.
Buy again: Yes
Padron
Padron 1964 Anniversary Maduro
Cigar
Consistently excellent
I've smoked dozens of these and they never disappoint. The maduro wrapper adds just the right amount of sweetness. A must-have in any humidor.
flavor: Dark chocolate, espresso, cedar
burn: Even
strength: Medium-Full
Buy again: Yes
Arturo Fuente
Arturo Fuente Opus X Reserva d'Chateau
Cigar
Powerful and unique
Very strong. Not an everyday smoke for me but impressive when you want something bold. The flavor profile is one of a kind.
flavor: Leather, cedar, pepper
strength: Full
Buy again: Maybe
Cohiba
Cohiba Robusto
Cigar
The Cuban benchmark
Smooth, creamy, and refined. That signature Cohiba grassiness is unmistakable. Burns perfectly every time. A true luxury smoke.
flavor: Cream, cedar, grass, honey, leather
burn: Even
strength: Medium-Full
Buy again: Yes
Macallan
Macallan 18 Year Sherry Oak
Spirits
Excellent but not my daily
Fantastic scotch, no question. But at this price point I'll save it for special occasions. The sherry notes are gorgeous though.
Buy again: Maybe
Woodford Reserve
Woodford Reserve Double Oaked
Spirits
The double oak makes all the difference
Deeper, richer, and more complex than standard Woodford. The second barrel really adds dark chocolate and caramel notes. One of my favorites.
nose: Dark chocolate, toasted oak, caramel
finish: Long, sweet, oaky
palate: Cherry, vanilla, oak, brown sugar
Buy again: Yes
Macallan
Macallan 18 Year Sherry Oak
Spirits
Worth the splurge
Beautifully balanced. The sherry cask influence is unmistakable. A touch pricey but you get what you pay for. Neat is the only way to drink this.
nose: Raisin, orange peel, vanilla
finish: Long and oaky
palate: Honey, spice, dried fruit
Buy again: Yes
Buffalo Trace
Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon
Spirits
Solid everyday pour
Great value bourbon. Nothing mind-blowing but consistently good. Perfect for mixing or casual sipping.
Buy again: Yes
Padron
Padron 1964 Anniversary Maduro
Nicaragua
Arturo Fuente
Opus X Reserva d'Chateau
Dominican Republic
Popular This Week
From member reviewsBlanton's
Blanton's Single Barrel Bourbon
Spirits
Lives up to the hype
Smooth, rich, and complex. The single barrel character really shines. Worth the hunt to find a bottle at retail.
nose: Caramel, vanilla, citrus
finish: Medium, warm, sweet
palate: Honey, oak, baking spice
Buy again: Yes
Drew Estate
Liga Privada No. 9
Cigar
Worth the hype
Rich, dark, and complex. The espresso and dark chocolate notes are incredible. Burns slow and cool. One of the best cigars I've ever smoked.
flavor: Chocolate, espresso, pepper, leather
burn: Even
strength: Full
Buy again: Yes
Padron
Padron 1964 Anniversary Maduro
Cigar
The gold standard
Perfect construction, perfect burn, perfect flavor. Cocoa, coffee, and pepper throughout. This is what every cigar should aspire to be.
flavor: Cocoa, coffee, cedar, pepper
burn: Even
strength: Medium-Full
Buy again: Yes